|
On November 25, 2001, researchers at a private biotechnology company called
Advanced Cell Technology announced that they had successfully cloned human
embryos. The scientists reported the results of two different methods
of producing human clones.
In the first method, they began with a donated human egg cell. They carefully
removed the cell's nucleus, and then replaced it with a cumulus cell,
which is a human cell that develops in the ovary with egg cells and supports
the growth of those egg cells. Cumulus cells are small enough that they
can be injected whole into the donor eggs. The scientists used 71 eggs
from seven volunteers to create a single cloned early embryo. Of the eggs
injected with cumulus cells, two made it to the four-cell embryo stage,
and one progressed to six cells, before its growth stopped.
The second method the scientists employed is called parthenogenesis.
In these studies, they exposed 22 eggs to chemicals that changed the eggs'
internal environment. Six of the eggs developed into what appeared to
be blastocysts, early embryos, but none progressed to develop the inner
cell mass that yields stem cells.
The researchers said that their studies were intended to be used for
therapeutic cloning, the creation of specific cell lines in the service
of fighting particular diseases or conditions. For example, they could
collect eggs from a woman with heart disease or diabetes. They would produce
blastocysts from her eggs and then use appropriate growth factors and
chemicals to induce those blastocysts to produce the heart muscle or insulin
cells that the patient needed, and then inject those healthy cells back
into her. Because they came from her own body, the woman would not be
likely to suffer rejection of those cells. This is not as easy to accomplish
for a man, but, theoretically, if two of his sperm cell nuclei were injected
into a donor egg, a blastocyst might develop. Two sperm would be needed
because eggs and sperm contain only half the necessary genetic material.
The response to the announcement by Advanced Cell Technology was varied,
but generally negative.
President George W. Bush condemned it, stating, "The use of embryos
to clone is wrong. We should not as a society grow life to destroy it.
And that's exactly what's taking place." He urged the Senate to act
on legislation already passed by the House of Representatives to ban human
cloning for any purposes. Senator Sam Brownback of Kansas stated that
he would introduce legislation to call for a six-month moratorium on cloning
research in order to permit more study. Senate Majority leader Tom Daschle
suggested that he would prefer not to rush legislation through the Senate
so that Senators could have time to understand the implications of the
research. The Vatican and the National Right to Life committee both condemned
the research.
Many in the scientific field expressed some skepticism over the reported
results. Indeed, the study was published in a non-peer reviewed format.
Although most will acknowledge that this a provocative first step towards
generating cloned human embryos that may provide useful stem cells, the
current study in no way demonstrated this utility. The embryos produced
did not reach the stage that would permit growth of stem cells. Indeed,
generating "cloned" embryos that containing DNA from a somatic
cell is not that difficult. Getting them to a stage where they provide
useful stem cells is likely to be much harder. Because of this, many scientists
believe that the report by ACT was done more for publicity then for the
advancement of science or medicine.
|