|
Within a short time of the announcement of the successful cloning of Dolly,
politicians around the world either instituted or proposed bans on attempts
at cloning humans. Then President Clinton issued a moratorium on the federal
funding of experiments for human cloning, and several states issued complete
bans on the research. In August 2001, the United State House of Representatives
voted to ban human cloning. Japan has passed a law providing for a 10-year
prison term for anyone found attempting to clone humans. Human cloning
experiments have been declared illegal in the United Kingdom, although
like the U.S., the U.K. has established a bioethics committee to study
the broader issue.
Lawmakers in the various nations have raised varied objections. Some
offer religious or moral concerns based on such issues as:
Taking reproduction
out of the arena of marriage and putting it into the laboratory.
The number of unsuccessful
animal cloning attempts that result in the production of non-viable or
defective embryos, with the euthanasia or "natural" death of
those embryos. Some religions define human life as beginning at conception,
and some religious and ethical leaders define cloned fetuses as fully
human and their destruction as immoral.
The fear that unscrupulous
people could try to clone a new "master race."
The reasons for controversy are many. Some object to cloning from religious
standpoints, considering the practice a form of "playing God."
A great many early animal clones have been unsuccessful, born with severe
birth defects. These animals' clones are euthanized, but that option would
clearly be unavailable to human parents of severely malformed clones.
|